Comic Book Hero Elimination Game

[cenquist]

Rules are simple. Add 1 to the character of choice and subtract 2 from the character of....dislike I guess! Just copy and paste the above list and see who is left standing. You may only vote for a character once a day. You cannot post back to back times.

Batman 10
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Gambit 10
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 10
Iron-Man 10
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 10
Superman 10
Wolverine 10
Wonder Woman 10


So many characters could have been put on this so if your favs were left off, sorry but I just kept it simple and stuck with DC/Marvel. :)

[cenquist]

Batman 10
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Gambit 10
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 11
Iron-Man 10
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 10
Superman 8
Wolverine 10
Wonder Woman 10

Superman -2 Howard the Duck +1

And that starts us off!

[paper]

Batman 10
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Gambit 10
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 9
Iron-Man 10
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 10
Superman 9
Wolverine 10
Wonder Woman 10

Superman + 1 Howard the Duck -2

[valoharth]

Batman 10
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 10
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 7
Iron-Man 10
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 10
Superman 9
Wolverine 10
Wonder Woman 10

Doctor Strange +1 Howard the Duck -2

[kahunablair]

Batman 10
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 8
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 7
Iron-Man 10
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 10
Superman 9
Wolverine 10
Wonder Woman 10

Green Lantern +1 Gambit -2

[cenquist]

Batman 10
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 9
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 7
Iron-Man 10
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 10
Superman 9
Wolverine 10
Wonder Woman 8

Gambit+1 Wonder Woman -2

Leave HTD alone!!!!

[jon_samuelson]

Batman 10
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 9
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 8
Howard The Duck 7
Iron-Man 10
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 11
Spider-Man 10
Starman 10
Superman 9
Wolverine 10
Wonder Woman 8

Silver Surfer: +1
Hawkman: -2

[JAFlanagan]

I'm really not sure I understand.

Batman 10
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Gambit 8
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 10
Iron-Man 10
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 11
Superman 10
Wolverine 10
Wonder Woman 10

Starman +1, Gambit -2.

[mari0]

Batman 11
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Gambit 8
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 10
Iron-Man 8
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 11
Superman 10
Wolverine 10
Wonder Woman 10

Batman +1
Iron-Man -2

[cenquist]

I'm really not sure I understand.

No real point....passes the time I guess...mere seconds...it doesn't solve anything either....hahaha. Maybe we should do a IFANBOY edition with the 4 of you! See who wins out! My money would be on Gordon....

[esophagus]

]Batman 12
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Gambit 8
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 10
Iron-Man 8
Nightwing 10
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 11
Superman 10
Wolverine 8
Wonder Woman 10

Batman +1, Wolverine -2

[meccaed]

Batman 12
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Gambit 8
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 10
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 11
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 11
Superman 10
Wolverine 8
Wonder Woman 10

+1 Nightwing, -2 Iron Man

[labor_days]

atman 12
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Gambit 8
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 10
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 11
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 12
Superman 10
Wolverine 6
Wonder Woman 10

Starman +1, Wolverine -2,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000 x infinity

[unnamedfrenchguy]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Gambit 8
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 10
Howard The Duck 10
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 11
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 8
Spider-Man 10
Starman 12
Superman 10
Wolverine 6
Wonder Woman 10

Batman +1, -2 Silver Surfer

[paper]

Be careful with the numbers. I think Josh set some of them back to 10 and people adjusted based on that. I think the list should look like this:

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 7
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 9
Howard The Duck 5
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 11
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 10
Starman 12
Superman 9
Wolverine 6
Wonder Woman 8

Howard the Duck -2 Hawkman +1

[kahunablair]

You are correct, Paper. Nice recovery.

[paulsharkey]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 7
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 5
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 11
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 9
Wolverine 6
Wonder Woman 8

Starman +1 Hawkman -2

[paper]

But Hawkman's awesome! What the hell!?

[paulsharkey]

But Hawkman's awesome! What the hell!?

It's the big stupid wings, and I hate people who don'tn wear shirts

[itsbecca]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 7
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 5
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 9
Wolverine 6
Wonder Woman 8

Nightwing +1 Power Girl -2

[luthor]

They play this endlessly on one of the toy forums I go to...and I'm never sure how it works. Alas...here I go...

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 5
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 5
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wolverine 6
Wonder Woman 8

Superman +1, Gambit -2

As an aside, how does Gambit make the list and The Hulk not?

[itsbecca]

As an aside, how does Gambit make the list and The Hulk not?

I'm sad he's not on there either. It would've made my decision on who to -2 a lot easier.




:)

[luthor]

I'm sad he's not on there either. It would've made my decision on who to -2 a lot easier.




:)

Oh, you're rotten. Shouldn't you be doing homework? ;)

[labor_days]

-2 to Power Girl? Really?

The original Supergirl that little girls dress up as gets a -2?

I am saddened.

edit: also, the the guy who started this thing broke his own rule and voted twice in the same day.

[iSteve]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 3
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wolverine 6
Wonder Woman 8

Howard the Duck +1 Gambit -2

[chelsea21]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 1
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 7
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wolverine 6
Wonder Woman 8

Howard The Duck +1 Gambit -2

I would have said +1 Nightwing but I can't let Howard down.

[iSteve]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 1
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 7
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wolverine 6
Wonder Woman 8

Howard The Duck +1 Gambit -2

Way to go Chelsea21. Howard needs our support!

[labor_days]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 1
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 7
Iron-Man 6
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wolverine 4
Wonder Woman 9

Wonder Woman +1, Wolverine -2

[tony-stark-hero]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit 1
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 5
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wolverine 4
Wonder Woman 9

Iron Man +1 Howard the Duck -2

[cenquist]

-2 to Power Girl? Really?

The original Supergirl that little girls dress up as gets a -2?

I am saddened.

edit: also, the the guy who started this thing broke his own rule and voted twice in the same day.


Rules are simple. Add 1 to the character of choice and subtract 2 from the character of....dislike I guess! Just copy and paste the above list and see who is left standing. You may only vote for a character once a day. You cannot post back to back times.

You can vote more than once a day, just not for the same person.

[cenquist]

I'm sad he's not on there either. It would've made my decision on who to -2 a lot easier.




:)

I just added the first guys that came to mind really. Until the list looked big enough.

[labor_days]

Yeah, I re-read it again. And voted for Wonder Woman.

[kahunablair]

Iron Man +1 Howard the Duck -2

You are a dick, Tony Stark!

[valoharth]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Gambit -1
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 5
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wolverine 4
Wonder Woman 9

Spiderman +1 Gambit -2

[cenquist]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 9
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wolverine 4
Wonder Woman 9

Howard The Duck +1 Gambit --gone

[gungadin]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 7
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wolverine 4
Wonder Woman 9

Superman +1, Silver Surfer -2

[paper]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 7
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wolverine 4
Wonder Woman 9

Powergirl +1 Green Lantern -2

[esophagus]

Green Lantern? Really? Wow.

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 10
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 7
Spider-Man 11
Starman 14
Superman 11
Wolverine 2
Wonder Woman 9

Starman +1, Wolverine -2

[esophagus]

Is anyone up to starting this over again with a massive list if I make one? This seems very limited. No offense to cenquist. Its a fun concept.

[conorkilpatrick]

Is anyone up to starting this over again with a massive list if I make one? This seems very limited. No offense to cenquist. Its a fun concept.

I think you should wait until this one is done. He started it, let it play out.

[gungadin]

Is anyone up to starting this over again with a massive list if I make one? This seems very limited. No offense to cenquist. Its a fun concept.

Let's finish this one first...

[kahunablair]

Keep it small, man. It's confusing people as it is.

[cenquist]

Is anyone up to starting this over again with a massive list if I make one? This seems very limited. No offense to cenquist. Its a fun concept.

I got no problem with it. If it is that large you might want to add one and subtract three or just start them at 5 or something.

[cenquist]

And 4 people post at exactly the same time.....I was out voted 3-1 I guess!!! Haha. Getting it too big could be harder to fit them all on the screen too.

[esophagus]

Alright then. :D

[cenquist]

Alright then. :D

Got no problem if you want to start the next one, once this one is done.

[esophagus]

For the record, I would have waited this one out if I knew it ended. How does it end?

[cenquist]

For the record, I would have waited this one out if I knew it ended. How does it end?

Until there is only one character left.....

[cenquist]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 12
Flash 10
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 7
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wolverine 2
Wonder Woman 9

Doctor Strange + Starman --

[labor_days]

Question: Which Green Lantern, Catwoman, Hawkman, Flash, Robin and Starman are we talking about?

Selina or Holly?

Hal, John, Guy, Alan or Kyle?

Carter Hall or Katar Hol?

Wally, Barry, Bart or Jay?

Dick, Jason, Tim or Stephanie?

There were like 6 Starmans. I assumed Jack Knight. But I am not sure if you meant Starman in JSA. Please specify.

[cenquist]

You are looking way to much into this....also notice how Marvel characters don't have this problem as much....

[esophagus]

You are looking way to much into this....also notice how Marvel characters don't have this problem as much....
Yeah, Marvel doesnt do legacy characters.

[paper]

You are looking way to much into this....also notice how Marvel characters don't have this problem as much....

Why don't you just come out and say it?

[labor_days]

You are looking way to much into this....also notice how Marvel characters don't have this problem as much....

Legacy. It's not a problem for me. I like them all for different reasons. John Stewart isn't his power ring and neither is Hal Jordan. But I would vote for Hal over John. Guy over Kyle. And likewise, Hal over Spider-Man but Spider-Man over John Stewart.

They are different characters. Not just costumes.

[cenquist]

Say what, I never meant is as a bad thing. Sorry if it came across that way.

[labor_days]

I'm just trying to figure out how I should vote or what I am voting for.

If you meant Jack Knight Starman, then he beats everyone mentioned in character and coolness.

If you mean Starman from the old Legion Of Super-Heroes and the current JSA, then I would vote for a few others first.

The same is true of Green Lantern (there is a whole corps of them ;) ) and Flash(es).

[valoharth]

If we start this up again we should segment it off, maybe do a Legcey list like all the Green Lanterns or do a X-men list but that one might get unruly

[cenquist]

Won't matter what you do, someone will always be unhappy with it.

[kahunablair]

Yeah, you guys really are talking this to death.
I know this is a comic forum, but geez is this getting over analyzed.

[labor_days]

Nah. It's unnecessary to have a list of legacy heroes and X-men. They are all different. The suggestion of a separate list for the X-men is nonsensical.

Jack Knight Starman is totally different from Starman in JSA. And I bet both Josh and I thought we were voting for Jack Knight. The options are flawed.

All one would have to do is specify. So that one can vote more clearly.

Green Lantern (Hal Jordan)
Catwoman (Selina Kyle)
Starman (Thom Kallor)
etc
etc

It's simple. It's logical. I know who I am voting for.

[valoharth]

Won't matter what you do, someone will always be unhappy with it.

Don't get me wrong I like this, its a cool idea. I was just saying that once were done with this we should just segment it to other ideas like: Who is the best in the 616 or Which member of the JSA is the best. Just nonsensical stuff like that.

[zattaric]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 12
Flash 10
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wolverine 2
Wonder Woman 10

Wonder Woman +1 Silver Surfer -2

[jon_samuelson]

Batman 13
Black Widow 10
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 12
Flash 10
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 8
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wolverine 3
Wonder Woman 10

Wolverine: +1
Hawkeye: -2

I refuse to let Wolverine go out like a bitch.

[paper]

Batman 13
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 12
Flash 10
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 8
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 12
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wolverine 3
Wonder Woman 10

Robin +1
Black Widow -2

[luthor]

Batman 13
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 12
Flash 10
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 8
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wolverine 1
Wonder Woman 10

Nightwing +1 Wolverine -2

[gungadin]

So are we all trying to kill Wolverine to see if he'll heal back?

[paper]

Batman 13
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 10
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 12
Flash 11
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 8
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 10

Flash +1
Wolverine -2 (Later, Logan) :D

[kahunablair]

Batman 13
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 8
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 8
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 6
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 10

Doctor Strange +1
Catwoman -2

[esophagus]

Batman 14
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 8
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 8
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 4
Iron-Man 7
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 10

Batman +1, Howard -2. Just die Howard.

[cenquist]

Batman 14
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 8
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 4
Iron-Man 5
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 10

Hawkeye+ Iron Man--

[labor_days]

Batman 14
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 6
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 4
Iron-Man 5
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11


Wonder Woman +1, Catwoman -2

[conorkilpatrick]

Batman 15
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 6
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 4
Iron Man 3
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11


Batman +1, Iron Man -2

[valoharth]

Batman 16
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 6
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 7
Howard The Duck 4
Iron Man 3
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 9


Bats +1 Wonder Woman -2

[kahunablair]

Batman 16
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 6
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 9
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 5
Howard The Duck 4
Iron Man 3
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 5
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 9


Hawkeye +1 Hawkman -2

[jmstump]

Batman 16
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 6
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 5
Howard The Duck 4
Iron Man 3
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 3
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 9

Green Lantern +1 Silver Surfer -2

[esophagus]

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 6
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 10
Hawkman 5
Howard The Duck 4
Iron Man 1
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 3
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 9

Batman +, Iron Man -

Whos going to do the deed and kill Mr. Stark?

[gungadin]

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 6
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 11
Hawkman 5
Howard The Duck 4
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 3
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 9

Hawkeye +1, Iron Man -2

I did! I did! No more Iron Man!

[esophagus]

Today could be a good day...

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 6
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 11
Hawkman 6
Howard The Duck 2
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 3
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 9

Hawkman +, Howard the Duck -

Now someone can kill Howard, and I'm done for a while.

[mikegraham6]

I hope im doing this right

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 6
Daredevil 11
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 11
Hawkman 6
Howard The Duck 0
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 3
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 9

Howard the Duck -2, bye bye
Daredevil +1

[labor_days]

You whipper-snappers don't have any appreciation of history. Voting off Howard the Duck! Pah!

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 11
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 11
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 3
Spider-Man 11
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 10

Wonder Woman +1, -2 Catwoman

[euchre0]

You whipper-snappers don't have any appreciation of history. Voting off Howard the Duck! Pah!
I know, right? I mean he was created an entire year before Wolverine!


Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 11
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 11
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 1
Spider-Man 12
Starman 12
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 10

Spider-Man +1; Silver Surfer -2

[luthor]

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 9
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 11
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 1
Spider-Man 12
Starman 12
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 10

Superman +1 Daredevil -2

[labor_days]

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 9
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 13
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 1
Spider-Man 12
Starman 13
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 10

Green Lantern (Hal Jordan I am assuming) +1, Hawkeye -2

[chelsea21]

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 9
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 11
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 14
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 1
Spider-Man 10
Starman 12
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 10

Nightwing +1 Spider-Man -2 but I'm not super happy about it.

[chelsea21]

Whoops, sorry about that.

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 9
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 14
Power Girl 9
Robin 11
Silver Surfer 1
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 10

[esophagus]

Silver Surfer only has one point left? Tempting.

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 9
Doctor Strange 13
Flash 11
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 14
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 1
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 10

Robin (Tim Drake) +1, Robin (Jason Todd) -2

[labor_days]

Hm. Yeah, that's the trouble with not specifying. Jason Todd : fail. Tim Drake : forever.

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 9
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 14
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 1
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 10

Power Girl +1, -2 Doctor Strange

[esophagus]

How lame is it that I keep getting very excited watching the characters die off. The suspense surrounding when Silver Surfer will go is killing me.

[mikegraham6]

i thought you could only do this once a day! Luthor, knowcking points of Daredevil?!?! what's wrong with you

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 14
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 1
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 10


REVENGE!
Supes -2
Daredevil +1

[esophagus]

i thought you could only do this once a day!
You can only vote for each CHARACTER once a day. I couldn't give Batman +1 five times today, but I could vote five times.

[chelsea21]

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 14
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Wonder Woman +1 Silver Surfer -2 Sorry but if the duck goes, you go.

[kahunablair]

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 14
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Green Lantern +1 Power Girl -2

[luthor]

i thought you could only do this once a day! Luthor, knowcking points of Daredevil?!?! what's wrong with you

REVENGE!
Supes -2
Daredevil +1

Mr Patriot lashes out against one of his own. Frankly, I'm hurt...so hurt that I need to kill someone.

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 15
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Silver Surfer 0
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 10

Nightwing +1 Silver Surfer -1(Can I use the extra point and take three away from Daredevil tomorrow?)

[conorkilpatrick]

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 4
Daredevil 8
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 16
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Nightwing +1, Daredevil -2

[esophagus]

Nightwing +1 Silver Surfer -1(Can I use the extra point and take three away from Daredevil tomorrow?)
Silver Surfer was dead already.

[horatio616]

Batman 17
Black Widow 8
Catwoman 2
Daredevil 9
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 6
Nightwing 16
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11


Catwoman -2, Daredevil +1

[paper]

Batman 17
Black Widow 6
Catwoman 2
Daredevil 9
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 7
Nightwing 16
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Hawkman +1
Black Widow -2

[paper]

Batman 15
Black Widow 6
Catwoman 2
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 7
Nightwing 16
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Daredevil +1
Batman -2

[gungadin]

Batman 17
Black Widow 6
Daredevil 9
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 9
Hawkman 7
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 8
Robin 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

I'm bitter at Catwoman cuz she was on NPR's In Character last night... and they cited the 60's TV series out the wazoo...

Nightwing +1
Catwoman -2 and DEAD!

[esophagus]

Thank you Paper! Hawkman must be redeemed.

[paper]

Batman 15
Black Widow 6
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 7
Hawkman 7
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Spider-Man 10
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Hawkeye -2
Power Girl +1

[kahunablair]

Batman 15
Black Widow 6
Daredevil 8
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 11
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 7
Hawkman 7
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Daredevil -2
Spider-Man +1

[esophagus]

Batman 15
Black Widow 4
Daredevil 8
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 12
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 7
Hawkman 7
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Black Widow -2, Giving my love to Flash.

[tony-stark-hero]

Batman 13
Black Widow 4
Daredevil 8
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 12
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 5
Hawkman 8
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Hawkman +1
Power Girl +1
Hawkeye -2
Batman -2

[kahunablair]

Batman 15
Black Widow 2
Daredevil 8
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 7
Hawkman 7
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Black Widow -2, Flash +1

[conorkilpatrick]

Hawkman +1
Power Girl +1
Hawkeye -2
Batman -2

This sets a bad precedent. One set of votes per post!

[kahunablair]

This sets a bad precedent. One set of votes per post!

It's ok. I skipped over it. The guy is a drunk anyway!

[labor_days]

Batman 15
Black Widow 2
Daredevil 8
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 7
Hawkman 5
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 9
Robin 10
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Superman +1, Hawkman -2


(This is getting dicey. I like Hawkman!)

[kahunablair]

Was that minus two for HawkEYE or HawkMAN, Labor?

[paper]

If you like Hawkman then take points off of Batman or Nightwing. Geez.

[labor_days]

Corrected.

And I like Batman and Nightwing that much more. Why must I choose between that which I love?

[kahunablair]

We need to do one of these for the Forum members.

Blair +1,587
Fred +2,343
Cardboard +1,943
Labor +2,124
Becca + 2,256
Paper - 3

[paper]

Paper +1
Blair -forever

[kahunablair]

Blair + Infinity
Paper - A whole Shit load!

[paper]

I can't believe how invested i am in Hawkman's safety. This game is cruel.

I literally read Labor's post and shouted, "This is bullshit!"

http://farm2.static.flickr.com/1176/558099710_44f98072e4.jpg

[labor_days]

I feel like a homeless man bussed in to vote for George W. Bush in Florida.

Feels like shame.

[zattaric]

Batman 15
Black Widow 2
Daredevil 6
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 7
Hawkman 5
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

-2 Daredevil +1 Power Girl

[zattaric]

Sorry forgot to delete the previous poster's votes. Mine were -2 Daredevil and +1 PG

[euchre0]

Batman 15
Daredevil 6
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 7
Hawkman 5
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Daredevil+1; Black Widow -2 (now she's gone)

Good Lord, how can Daredevil have such a low number?

Lower than Doctor Strange and Power Girl? This game is mind-boggling.

[luthor]

You can go minus 2? If I had known, Daredevil would be dead by now.

[conorkilpatrick]

You can go minus 2? If I had known, Daredevil would be dead by now.

It's always minus 2.

[paper]

You can go minus 2? If I had known, Daredevil would be dead by now.

Who doesn't like Daredevil?!

[conorkilpatrick]

Who doesn't like Daredevil?!

Kingpin.

[luthor]

and I look like Kingpin. So I have to hate him.

EDIT: I'm havinga slightly more retarded day then usual. You'll forgive my idiocy.

[iSteve]

Batman 15
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 7
Hawkman 3
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 11
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Daredevil +1, Hawkman -2

[paper]

Hawkman, I shall avenge you!

[conorkilpatrick]

Batman 15
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 7
Hawkman 4
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 9
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Hawkman +1, Spider-Man -2

[cenquist]

Batman 15
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 8
Hawkman 2
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 9
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Hawkman-- Hawkeye+

[animalvader1]

Batman 15
Captain America 1
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 8
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 9
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Hawkman -2 , Captain America +1:D

[esophagus]

Hawkman should have been at least one of the last five standing. I'm pissed. I'm also killing Captain America, since he wasn't here to start with.

Batman 15
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 18
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 9
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Nightwing +1, Hawkeye -2 (You take my hawk, I'll take yours)

[labor_days]

Batman 15
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 14
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 8
Hawkman 2
Nightwing 17
Power Girl 10
Robin 8
Spider-Man 9
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Flash (Waly West) +1, Robin (Jason Todd) -2

[esophagus]

The official standings as of now (taking into account the simultaneous posts by labor and I):

Batman 15
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 18
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 9
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

[animalvader1]

Batman 15
Captain America 15
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 11
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 16
Power Girl 10
Robin 10
Spider-Man 9
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Nightwing -2, Captain America (who should have been on the list in the first place) +15 (For unsportsmanlike conduct.)

Just kidding. Disregard my posts if you want, I'm outa here.

[conorkilpatrick]

Batman 15
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 9
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 18
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 9
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Robin +1, Doctor Strange -2

[animalvader1]

No love for Doc Strange dude? The Vaughan mini was great.

[cenquist]

Batman 15
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 18
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 9
Starman 13
Superman 9
Wonder Woman 11

Supes-- Doc Strange+

Ya, Vaughan mini was great.

[labor_days]

Yeah but Dr. Strange has had too many years of horrible shite.

Batman 16
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 18
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 7
Starman 13
Superman 9
Wonder Woman 11

Batman +1, Spider-Man -2

[esophagus]

At this point all of the characters I actively dislike are gone. Now its all about who needs to win.

Batman 16
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 18
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 5
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Superman +1, Spiderman -2

[cenquist]

Batman 16
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 18
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 6
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Spider-Man + Green Lantern--

[esophagus]

Batman 14
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 19
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 6
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Batman -, Nightwing +

Dick Grayson will win.

[casually-drowned]

Batman 12
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 20
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 6
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Batman-, Nightwing+

[kahunablair]

Batman 10
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 20
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 6
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Batman--, Superman+

[conorkilpatrick]

Batman 11
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 20
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 4
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

Batman +1, Spider-Man -2

[acomicbookgirl]

Batman 9
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 21
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 4
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 11

EDIT: Batman -2, Nightwing +1

[conorkilpatrick]

Batman 9
Daredevil 10
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 10
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 20
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 4
Starman 13
Superman 10
Wonder Woman 11

Something's wrong with your numbers here. Did you vote for four people?

[kahunablair]

Something's wrong with your numbers here. Did you vote for four people?

She has a lot of love to give!

[acomicbookgirl]

Something's wrong with your numbers here. Did you vote for four people?

Fixed it. Sorry.

[kahunablair]

Looks like she fixed it.


Batman 9
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 4
Starman 13
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 9

WonderWoman-2 Nightwing+1

[casually-drowned]

Batman 9
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 4
Starman 14
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 7

Wonder Woman-, Starman+

[esophagus]

Batman 9
Daredevil 7
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 4
Starman 15
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 5

Wonder Woman -, Starman +

[acomicbookgirl]

Batman 9
Daredevil 5
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 4
Starman 15
Superman 11
Wonder Woman 6

EDIT: Wonder Woman +1, Daredevil -2

[conorkilpatrick]

Batman 9
Daredevil 3
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 4
Starman 15
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 5

Daredevil -2, Superman +1

[kahunablair]

Conor, ACBG beat you to it, brother.

[esophagus]

Numbers as it stands:

Batman 9
Daredevil 3
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 4
Starman 15
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 6

[kahunablair]

Batman 9
Daredevil 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 13
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Spider-Man 2
Starman 15
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 6

Daredevil + SpiderMan--

[casually-drowned]

Batman 9
Daredevil 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 14
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Starman 15
Superman 12
Wonder Woman 6

Spiderman- (86), Flash+

[gungadin]

Batman 7
Daredevil 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 14
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Starman 15
Superman 13
Wonder Woman 6

Superman +1, Batman -2

[casually-drowned]

Good looking out Conor. Sorry.

[gungadin]

Batman 7
Daredevil 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 14
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Starman 16
Superman 13
Wonder Woman 4

Starman +1, Wonder Woman -2

[casually-drowned]

Batman 5
Daredevil 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 14
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Starman 16
Superman 13
Wonder Woman 4

Batman-, Nightwing+

[esophagus]

The stroke of midnight is upon us...

Batman 3
Daredevil 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 14
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 24
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Starman 16
Superman 13
Wonder Woman 4

Batman -, Nightwing +

[casually-drowned]

Batman 3
Daredevil 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 14
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 24
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Starman 17
Superman 13
Wonder Woman 2

Wonder Woman-, Starman+

[esophagus]

Batman 3
Daredevil 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 14
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Starman 18
Superman 13

Wonder Womans dead, Starman +1

[casually-drowned]

Batman 3
Daredevil 2
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 15
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Starman 18
Superman 13

Daredevil-, Flash+

[esophagus]

Batman 3
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 16
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 10
Robin 11
Starman 18
Superman 13

Killed Daredevil, +1 Flash

[labor_days]

So you guys took out Wonder Woman and Spider-man before Doctor Strange and Hawkeye, huh? /is ashamed of you people

[esophagus]

Batman 3
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 16
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 10
Robin 12
Starman 18
Superman 11

Superman -, Robin +

[meccaed]

Batman 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 16
Green Lantern 10
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 8
Robin 12
Starman 18
Superman 11

Batman +1, Power Girl -2

[casually-drowned]

Batman 4
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 16
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 8
Robin 12
Starman 18
Superman 9

Superman-, Green Lantern+

[acomicbookgirl]

Batman 2
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 16
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 8
Robin 12
Starman 18
Superman 9

Batman -, Green Lantern +

[gungadin]

Batman ZERO
Doctor Strange 10
Flash 16
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 24
Power Girl 8
Robin 12
Starman 18
Superman 9

Batman -2, Nightwing +1

Sorry, Bats.... But... you's old...

[paper]

Doctor Strange 10
Flash 16
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 4
Nightwing 24
Power Girl 8
Robin 13
Starman 18
Superman 9

Robin (Tim) +1
Hawkeye -2

[paper]

oops.....

[paper]

whoops....

[mikegraham6]

this is the sadest thread i've ever seen, Eso you killed of Daredevil?!?!? you're dead to me now. only the lame ass characters are left now

Doctor Strange 8
Flash 16
Green Lantern 13
Hawkeye 4
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 7
Robin 13
Starman 18
Superman 10

Power Girl -2
Green Lantern +1

EDIT: Three posts in a row Paper?!? is that legal

[paper]

Apparently it is against the rules.

Please ignore my second and third posts.

[mikegraham6]

Forget

[mikegraham6]

all about

[mikegraham6]

it

(10)

[paper]

Adjusted list.

Doctor Strange 10
Flash 16
Green Lantern 13
Hawkeye 4
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 13
Starman 18
Superman 9

Powergirl +1
Nightwing -2

[paper]

Shit. Mike. The three post thing is against the rules. Edit your second and third posts like I just did. then use my most recent list and you can do your second vote.

[mikegraham6]

Doctor Strange 8
Flash 16
Green Lantern 13
Hawkeye 5
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 13
Starman 18
Superman 9

Doctor Strange -2
Hawkeye +1

[paper]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 16
Green Lantern 13
Hawkeye 5
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 13
Starman 18
Superman 10

Superman +1
Doctor Strange -2

[mikegraham6]

so i guess according to the rules, i have to wait for someone to post a reply before i can adjust the list again right?
If so:

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 17
Green Lantern 13
Hawkeye 5
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 13
Starman 18
Superman 8

Supes -2
Flash +1

[paper]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 18
Green Lantern 11
Hawkeye 5
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 13
Starman 18
Superman 8

Flash +1
Green Lantern -2

[jmstump]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 18
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 5
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 13
Starman 18
Superman 6

Green Lantern +1 Superman -2

Why do I feel like there are a lot of Green Lantern haters on here? Don't be hatin'

[mikegraham6]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 18
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 5
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 11
Starman 19
Superman 6

Robin -2
Starman +1

Wait.... which Starman are we talking about here???

[jmstump]

I've been wondering that too. I assumed since Josh set the stance by being the first to add one to him that it's the newer one.

[mikegraham6]

I've been wondering that too. I assumed since Josh set the stance by being the first to add one to him that it's the newer one.
see i would think the opposite, Josh loves the James Robinson Starman (unless you think this is the newer one....)
but who doesn't love the kooky Geoff John's Starman from JSA????

[cenquist]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 18
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 6
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 11
Starman 19
Superman 4

Supes-- Hawkeye+

[iSteve]

Doctor Strange 7
Flash 18
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 4
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 11
Starman 19
Superman 4

Doctor Strange +1, Hawkeye -2

[esophagus]

Doctor Strange 7
Flash 18
Green Lantern 12
Hawkeye 4
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 8
Robin 12
Starman 19
Superman 2

Superman -, Robin +

[euchre0]

Good gravy! I last checked this thread around 8 last night. 12 hours later, the best characters are gone and we still have Power Girl and Starman? There seems to be a large DC bias here...which is even more baffling that Dr. Strange and Hawkeye are left? Is everyone here a comic writer? I was under the impression that only 50 year old comic writers were in love with Dr. Strange.

Doctor Strange 7
Flash 18
Green Lantern 13
Hawkeye 4
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 6
Robin 12
Starman 19
Superman 2

Green Lantern +1; Power Girl -2

[esophagus]

DC bias? Batman and Wonder Woman are dead.

[kahunablair]

Doctor Strange 7
Flash 18
Green Lantern 13
Hawkeye 4
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 6
Robin 12
Starman 19

Starman+1
Superman -2

Blair is Kryptonite, baby!

[euchre0]

DC bias? Batman and Wonder Woman are dead.
By pure numbers, DC has 6 to Marvel's 2 at this point and Nightwing and Starman, who are certainly not in the foreground of the DC franchise are leading with overwhelming numbers.

The rules say we can only vote for a character once a day, right? That goes for both positive and negative votes, correct?

Doctor Strange 5
Flash 19
Green Lantern 13
Hawkeye 4
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 6
Robin 12
Starman 19

Flash +1; Doctor Strange -2

[luthor]

You killed Superman? I don't think I can be friends with you people anymore...

[iSteve]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 19
Green Lantern 13
Hawkeye 2
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 6
Robin 12
Starman 19

Doctor Strange +1, Hawkeye -2

[euchre0]

I don't think you can vote for Dr. Strange, Steve, since we are only to vote for a character once per day. If that wasn't that case, Spider-Man would have 65 points right now.

[acomicbookgirl]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 19
Green Lantern 14
Hawkeye DEAD
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 6
Robin 12
Starman 19

Hawkeye -, Green Lantern +

[kahunablair]

You killed Superman? I don't think I can be friends with you people anymore...

http://img26.picoodle.com/img/img26/4/3/18/f_untitledm_fdd7b7b.png

[horatio616]

Friggin' Starman?

Jeez! Look at this DC bias! Damn Liberal message boards! ;)

Doctor Strange 7
Flash 19
Green Lantern 14
Hawkeye DEAD
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 6
Robin 12
Starman 17

Starman -2, Doctor Strange +1

Friggin' Dr. Strange?

[acomicbookgirl]

Friggin' Starman?

Jeez! Look at this DC bias! Damn Liberal message boards! ;)

Doctor Strange 7
Flash 19
Green Lantern 14
Hawkeye DEAD
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 6
Robin 12
Starman 17

Starman -2, Doctor Strange +1

Friggin' Dr. Strange?

Um, Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman are dead.. And saying that still doesn't sit well with me..

[horatio616]

Um, Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman are dead.. And saying that still doesn't sit well with me..

Just wait. I'm sure somehow some embarrassing photos of Dr. Strange will pop up or some story will come out that his teacher, The Ancient One, blames the government for 9/11.

[euchre0]

Um, Batman, Superman and Wonder Woman are dead.. And saying that still doesn't sit well with me..

So are Spider-Man and Wolverine. In any case, there are 6 DC characters left, While only one representative of Marvel. How can you argue that? In fact, of the characters left, they show a deeper appreciation for DC than if just Superman and Batman were still around.

Still, We are only kidding about any kinds of bias. I don't have allegiances on way or another. I just didn't expect it to be so lopsided.

I really need to read Starman is his short series showed him to be a better character than all the others except Nightwing.

Also, Dr. Strange should have 6, since steve voted for him twice in under an hour. I'm on to your shenanigans, Steve! That trippy cloak wearing mystic is going down!

[esophagus]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 20
Green Lantern 14
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 4
Robin 12
Starman 17

Flash +1, Powergirl -2

Edit: Put Dr. Strange to six, because Steve cheeeeeated.

[horatio616]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 21
Green Lantern 12
Nightwing 22
Power Girl 4
Robin 12
Starman 17

Flash +1, Green Lantern -2

[esophagus]

Flash, Starman, and Nightwing. I like where this is going. My evil plot paid off.

[euchre0]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 21
Green Lantern 12
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 4
Robin 12
Starman 15

Nightwing +1, Starman -2

[esophagus]

Looking back at the original list the only chance Marvel realy had was Spider-Man, and possibly Wolverine, and they're gone. I don't think it's as much a bias as them just not being accurately represented. Something tells me Captain America could have taken this by storm.

[xebix]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 21
Green Lantern 13
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 2
Robin 12
Starman 15

Green Lantern + 1 Power Girl -2

[euchre0]

Looking back at the original list the only chance Marvel realy had was Spider-Man, and possibly Wolverine, and they're gone. I don't think it's as much a bias as them just not being accurately represented. Something tells me Captain America could have taken this by storm.

That's a good point. When this game is played out, are you still willing to compile a massive list?

[horatio616]

Looking back at the original list the only chance Marvel realy had was Spider-Man, and possibly Wolverine, and they're gone. I don't think it's as much a bias as them just not being accurately represented. Something tells me Captain America could have taken this by storm.

I really think this runs deeper. DC has been doing a good job of tapping into people's nostalgia with this Silver Age revival and the legacy angle, while Marvel has been steadily turning their characters into assholes. I know this hasn't really had an affect on sales, but when DC fans talk about DC characters, it's with more reverence.

[jon_samuelson]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 19
Green Lantern 14
Nightwing 23
Power Girl 2
Robin 12
Starman 15

Green Lantern +1
Flash -2

[esophagus]

That's a good point. When this game is played out, are you still willing to compile a massive list?
Yeah, I've already got it ready.

Of course, I keep thinking of mroe people to add to it, but dont' want it to be too enormous.

I've also written up rules, as the points system will need to change with a bigger list, and I know certain people have been confused by this.

[luthor]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 19
Green Lantern 14
Nightwing 24
Power Girl 0
Robin 12
Starman 15


Nightwing +1 Powergirl -2

[chelsea21]

Doctor Strange 6
Flash 17
Green Lantern 14
Nightwing 25
Robin 12
Starman 15

Nightwing +1 Flash -2

What happened to Batman?! Not cool.

[esophagus]

I'm appalled that Dr. Strange is not dead yet.

[acomicbookgirl]

I'm appalled that Dr. Strange is not dead yet.

The day has only begun.. ;)

[acomicbookgirl]

Oh crap! I voted for him already.. Damn it!

[jmstump]

see i would think the opposite, Josh loves the James Robinson Starman (unless you think this is the newer one....)
but who doesn't love the kooky Geoff John's Starman from JSA????

Too many Starman make JM head hurt.

Doctor Strange 4
Flash 17
Green Lantern 14
Nightwing 25
Robin 12
Starman 16

Starman +1 Doc Strange -2

[labor_days]

Doctor Strange 2
Flash 17
Green Lantern 15
Nightwing 25
Robin 12
Starman 16

Green Lantern +1, Doctor Strange -2

[luthor]

Doctor Strange 0
Flash 18
Green Lantern 15
Nightwing 25
Robin 12
Starman 16

Flash +1 Doctor Strange -2

[labor_days]

Flash 18
Green Lantern 15
Nightwing 25
Robin 10
Starman 17

Starman (Jack Knight) up, Robin (Jason Todd) down

[luthor]

Flash 18
Green Lantern 15
Nightwing 25
Robin 11
Starman 15

This is the only place on the internet Starman would still be alive but Batman. Wonder Woman and Superman would all be dead.

Robin(Jason Todd) +1 Starman -2

[casually-drowned]

I'm appalled that Dr. Strange is not dead yet.

I love that THIS is what you are appalled at.

[acomicbookgirl]

This is the only place on the internet Starman would still be alive but Batman. Wonder Woman and Superman would all be dead.



I'm still trying to get over that...

[labor_days]

Luthor, I demand to know which Starman you slighted! /shakes fist

Flash 19
Green Lantern 15
Nightwing 23
Robin 11
Starman 15

Flash (Wally) up, Nightwing (Kara Zor-L) down

[kahunablair]

Flash 19
Green Lantern 16
Nightwing 23
Robin 9
Starman 15

Green Latern (All of them) +1 Robin (All of them) -2

[kahunablair]

Your Nightwing math is off, Labor. I fixed it in my post though.

[luthor]

Luthor, I demand to know which Starman you slighted! /shakes fist

The one with the stupid costume. Oh wait...that's all of them.

[acomicbookgirl]

Flash 19
Green Lantern 17
Nightwing 23
Robin 7
Starman 15

Green Lantern +, Robin -

[labor_days]

The one with the stupid costume. Oh wait...that's all of them.

This is how I feel after reading your post.

http://i32.tinypic.com/25hlr7n.jpg

[kahunablair]

Sad part is we can't really vote now if we did it more then a few times today. The only character I could actually change is Flash now.

[conorkilpatrick]

Flash 17
Green Lantern 17
Nightwing 24
Robin 7
Starman 15

Nightwing +1, Flash -2

[jon_samuelson]

Flash 17
Green Lantern 17
Nightwing 22
Robin 7
Starman 16

Starman +1
Nightwing -2

[esophagus]

We've gotten to the point where two votes a day is the maximum possible. We'll be here for a long while at this point.

I say two votes per character for the duration, unless those two votes could kill said character. Anyone agree?

[valoharth]

Flash 17
Green Lantern 18
Nightwing 22
Robin 7
Starman 14

GL +1 Starman -2

[euchre0]

I say two votes per character for the duration, unless those two votes could kill said character. Anyone agree?

No. Rules are rules. Unless Starman is going to win. Then all rules are forfeit.

Starman? Seriously?*



*It's a bit late in the game, but this is my new footnote for every time I post in this thread.

[labor_days]

Jack Knight Starman was one of the coolest and best written characters in the history of comics. Jack Knight should be held in higher regard than a lot of other characters. Nostalgia aside.

A few of the other Starman(s) are fun. But Jack Knight? Whole different league of awesome.

[euchre0]

I haven't read it yet, obviously, but I still like to poke fun at the fact so many people like him better than characters with much more history and story. I loved "Y:the Last Man" immensely, but I couldn't say Yorick is one of my favorite characters, even though his series was stupendous.

Plus, until recently, I hadn't heard the continual love for Starman. Maybe I just wasn't paying attention, but it still feels like such an "out of left field" choice.

[horatio616]

I'm partial to Ditko's Prince Gavyn Starman from the 1980s. I used to read his stories in Adventure Comics from time-to-time as a child.

http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a178/taintedlunch/crstarm.jpg

[kahunablair]

I thought it was Mario's Starman!
http://img.qj.net/uploads/articles_module/109255/Mario_Stars_qjgenth.jpg

I feel cheated....

[esophagus]

I haven't read it yet, obviously, but I still like to poke fun at the fact so many people like him better than characters with much more history and story. I loved "Y:the Last Man" immensely, but I couldn't say Yorick is one of my favorite characters, even though his series was stupendous.

Plus, until recently, I hadn't heard the continual love for Starman. Maybe I just wasn't paying attention, but it still feels like such an "out of left field" choice.That's a silly way of looking at things. Being around for a long time does not make something quality, quality makes something quality. Yorick should be your favorite character if you enjoy him more than Batman, regardless of whether or not Batman has been around longer.

[paper]

Gambit has been around much longer than Yorick Brown. Guess who's a better character?

Though it can often help, time does not equate quality. Quality equates quality.

[euchre0]

That's a silly way of looking at things. Being around for a long time does not make something quality, quality makes something quality. Yorick should be your favorite character if you enjoy him more than Batman, regardless of whether or not Batman has been around longer.

It's not that I think longevity=good. Far from it. I am just surprised that people who have read comics for a long time would declare a recent character as their favorite. I've been reading Spider-Man since 1992, some good, some bad. I discovered Y about a year ago. The fact that I've known one 15 years longer isn't the reason I like Spider-Man more than Yorick, but because I have liked him enough to buy books every month since 1992, I would assume that he would have to be one of my favorite characters. Does that make any more sense? Probably not?

Of course, it all comes down to taste and I am sure I will like Starman a great deal when I read it. My surprise comes with the assumption that most people here have been reading comics for a while, meaning they would have probably started with Batman, Spider-Man, etc. as opposed to breaking in with those lesser known characters. That's not to say that lesser known means lesser in quality.

[esophagus]

It's not that I think longevity=good. Far from it. I am just surprised that people who have read comics for a long time would declare a recent character as their favorite. I've been reading Spider-Man since 1992, some good, some bad. I discovered Y about a year ago. The fact that I've known one 15 years longer isn't the reason I like Spider-Man more than Yorick, but because I have liked him enough to buy books every month since 1992, I would assume that he would have to be one of my favorite characters. Does that make any more sense? Probably not?

Of course, it all comes down to taste and I am sure I will like Starman a great deal when I read it. My surprise comes with the assumption that most people here have been reading comics for a while, meaning they would have probably started with Batman, Spider-Man, etc. as opposed to breaking in with those lesser known characters. That's not to say that lesser known means lesser in quality.If you haven't guessed by now, no one likes Power Girl more than Batman, Spider-Man, and Wonder Woman. This thread isn't a good judgement. Just us having fun.

I think if you are going to look at it that way, look into hypothetical situations. If Y had kept going for 15 years, youd probably keep bying it, no? If you would then it's quality now that matters.

[labor_days]

Gambit has been around much longer than Yorick Brown. Guess who's a better character?

Though it can often help, time does not equate quality. Quality equates quality.

This guy. This fucking guy. Am I right?

"Quality equates quality", I had a lump in my throat as I read that. That was beautiful, Papes.

[esophagus]

This guy. This fucking guy. Am I right?

"Quality equates quality", I had a lump in my throat as I read that. That was beautiful, Papes.He could certainly get his own material. :rolleyes:
being around for a long time does not make something quality, quality makes something qualitytime does not equate quality. Quality equates quality.

[paper]

It's not that I think longevity=good. Far from it. I am just surprised that people who have read comics for a long time would declare a recent character as their favorite. I've been reading Spider-Man since 1992, some good, some bad. I discovered Y about a year ago. The fact that I've known one 15 years longer isn't the reason I like Spider-Man more than Yorick, but because I have liked him enough to buy books every month since 1992, I would assume that he would have to be one of my favorite characters. Does that make any more sense? Probably not?

The problem with that argument is that you're assuming we each have the same admiration for older characters and that we all agree about the consistency of their excellence. You suggest that it's not simply longevity, but our own tolerance for the character over time. Not that they're long-standing, but that they're long-standing and popular for much of that lifespan. But this potentially hurts our love for a character. Yorick's a weekend vacation with your buddies. Superman is living in an apartment with your buddies for several years. Good days and bad days.

I'd argue that it's actually easier to predict the popularity of a newer character--and the extent of their mass appeal--in contrast to an older character. My Superman is not your Superman because there are seemingly countless points of entry into the Superman franchise. Which books did you read, which movies and television series? No one here has read everything with Superman's name on it. We've only experienced part of the story. Some for worse and some for better.