A podcast Review Show.

[rayjay1999]

It Would be awesome if we could see dan huard Reviewing Podcasts? What do you think. I know G4techtv Canada has a Show Like that. But they don't critsize podcasts.

[tempesta]

wouldn't that be potentially alienating to avenues of promotion? ....or completely lacking in integrity? depending on which avenue rev3 would take an idea like this?

[rayjay1999]

Originally Posted by tempesta

wouldn't that be potentially alienating to avenues of promotion? ....or completely lacking in integrity? depending on which avenue rev3 would take an idea like this?

They could review there own shows too. My feeling though is some people want to know what garbage they are putting in there IPods. Do you Think Getting Drunk on air or Doing Scenes With Strippers is Integrity? Because thats what Some Shows (I.E. Diggnation and The Broken) on Revision 3 Do. Let's not forget Infected Ether. I know Indigital and Systm have Integrity? But Like I said Rev 3 is not a Tech tv like Podcast network. and about Alienating to avenues of Promotion. I Don't see Revision 3 Doing that With something like that with this.
I mean totally Rad show already reviews movies why Can't Revision 3 have a Show about Podcast?

[tnvwboy]

Given the huge number of podcasts out there this could be nice. I think it'd have to be broken into two types of podcasts, audio and video. Hell even review if the video podcast still works if you are listening to just the audio version (Cranky Geeks as an example).

All in all I think this could work. I think the fact that Rev3 is a podcast 'network' is irrelevant. If nothing else it could be a way to scout other great 'shows' for licensing or acquisition.

[jchaosrs]

This actually seems like a great idea. I know I would watch/listen to it. With the immense amount of bad podcasts floating around it would be nice to have a show that can sort through it all.

There is so much that goes into making a good quality podcast so having a show that can break it down show by show would great.

They could review there own shows too. My feeling though is some people want to know what garbage they are putting in there IPods. Do you Think Getting Drunk on air or Doing Scenes With Strippers is Integrity? Because thats what Some Shows (I.E. Diggnation and The Broken) on Revision 3 Do. Let's not forget Infected Ether. I know Indigital and Systm have Integrity??

Just a question, but what do drinking and strippers have to do with integrity? That doesn't really seem amoral or unethical.

Besides, drunks and strippers are people too!

[takdiego]

I think it's a great idea, there are so many, to simply spotlight a few a week, with multiple podcast listeners' opinions...would be fair and I think would work great

[comhcinc]

most podcast are just review shows with a couple of "how to's" thrown in the mix. so what you are asking for is a review show for review show.........that doesn't make any sense.